Witness index – First trial

Videos can be found here:
https://www.courttv.com/trials/ca-v-menendez-1993/

OPJ is shorthand for “outside the presence of the jury.” Everything else should be pretty self-explanatory.
There were a ton of hearings during the trial, often in the middle of a witness’ testimony. I have chosen to not indicate when such hearings took place.

VIDEO 1
No witnesses

VIDEO 2
No witnesses

VIDEO 3
Christine Nye – 0:00 – (Both juries)
Avrille Krom – 14:00 – (Both juries)
Michael Butkus – 34:50 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 4
Kirk West – 12:20 – (Both juries)
Bob Anderson – 48:15 – (Both juries)
Richard Catalani – 1:28:10 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 5
Leslie Zoeller – 0:00 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 6
Thomas Edmonds – 0:00 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 7
Dwight Van Horn – 0:00 – (OPJ)
Dwight Van Horn – 40:00 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 8
Perry Berman – 0:00 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 9
Craig Cignarelli – 1:20:34 – (OPJ)

VIDEO 10
Craig Cignarelli – 0:00 – (Erik’s jury)

VIDEO 11
Donovan Goodreau – 0:00 – (Both juries)
Donovan Goodreau – 54:20 – (Lyle’s jury)
Donovan Goodreau – 1:05:40 – (OPJ)
Donovan Goodreau – 2:01:14 – (OPJ)

VIDEO 12
Robert Rand – 0:00 – (OPJ)
Glenn Stevens – 11:00 – (OPJ)
Richard Wenskoski – 35:00 – (Lyle’s jury)
Richard Wenskoski – 1:10:29 – (OPJ)
Richard Wenskoski – 2:17:55 – (Lyle’s jury)
Amanda Adams Geier – 2:25:15 – (Both juries)
Glenn Stevens – 3:28:24 – (Lyle’s jury)

VIDEO 13
Glenn Stevens – 13:07 – (Lyle’s jury)
Glenn Stevens – 1:15:00 – (OPJ)
Glenn Stevens – 1:28:39 – (Lyle’s jury)
Donovan Goodreau – 2:26:54 – (Lyle’s jury)
Donovan Goodreau – 3:12:59 – (Both juries)
Wesley Grose – 3:15:06 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 14
Jerome Oziel – 2:16:33 – (OPJ)

VIDEO 15
Jerome Oziel – 28:25 – (OPJ)

VIDEO 16
Edward Hayman – 16:47 – (Erik’s jury)
Deborah Hayman – 54:54 – (Erik’s jury)
Howard Witkin – 1:30:00 – (Lyle’s jury)
Howard Witkin – 2:37:45 – (Erik’s jury)
Mary Ellen Mahar – 3:15:18 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 17
Irwin Golden – 1:12:17 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 18
Irwin Golden – 7:35 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 19
Jerome Oziel – 49:35 – (Erik’s jury)
Jerome Oziel – 1:24:35 – (Both juries)
Jerome Oziel – 2:03:32 – (Lyle’s jury)
Jerome Oziel – 2:16:30 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 20
Jerome Oziel – 6:55 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 21
Jerome Oziel – 0:00 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 22
Jerome Oziel – 0:00 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 23
Jeffrey Lulow – 0:00 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 24
Jerome Oziel – 0:00 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 25
Jerome Oziel – 0:00 – (Both juries)
Jerome Oziel – 1:42:00 – (Erik’s jury)

VIDEO 26
Leslie Zoeller – 9:35 – (Erik’s jury)
Leslie Zoeller – 2:33:09 – (Lyle’s jury)

VIDEO 27
Bradley Brunon – 0:00 – (Both juries)
Henrique Llanio – 31:20 – (OPJ)
Stephen Goldberg – 1:48:00 – (OPJ)

VIDEO 28
Valerie Hart – 15:56 – (OPJ)
Mark Heffernan – 29:45 – (OPJ)
Leslie Zoeller – 49:00 – (Lyle’s jury)
Leslie Zoeller – 50:20 – (Both juries)
PROSECUTION RESTS CASE AGAINST LYLE – 1:34:24
Mark Heffernan – 1:43:09 – (Erik’s jury)

VIDEO 29
Valerie Hart – 14:23 – (Erik’s jury)
Leslie Zoeller – 43:13 – (Erik’s jury)
PROSECUTION RESTS CASE AGAINST ERIK – 53:40
DEFENSE CASE BEGINS
Marta Cano – 1:43:41 – (Both juries)
Marta Cano – 1:57:05 – (OPJ)

VIDEO 30
John Briere – 0:00 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 31
Brian Alan Andersen, Jr. – 45:39 – (Both juries)
Brian Alan Andersen, Jr. – 1:16:41 – (OPJ)
Brian Alan Andersen, Jr. – 1:27:17 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 32
Kathleen Simonton – 1:01:57 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 33
Diane Vander Molen – 0:00 – (Both juries)
Diane Vander Molen – 42:20 – (OPJ)
Diane Vander Molen – 1:02:03 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 34
Cynthia McPhee – 1:12:52 – (OPJ)
Cynthia McPhee – 2:09:10 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 35
Charles Wadlington – 0:00 – (Both juries)
Meredith Geisler – 1:56:45 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 36
Marianne Cano – 0:00 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 37
Marta Cano – 0:00 – (Both juries)
Marta Cano – 2:06:27 – (OPJ)

VIDEO 38
Marta Cano – 34:55 – (Both juries)
Marta Cano – 1:48:26 – (Erik’s jury)

VIDEO 39
Stephen Mosner – 0:00 – (Both juries)
Jessica Goldsmith – 18:20 – (Both juries)
Robert Clouse – 36:28 – (Lyle’s jury)
Patricia Cross – 57:38 – (Lyle’s jury)
Faith Goldsmith – 1:15:14 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 40
William Kurtain – 16:20 – (Both juries)
Alicia Hercz – 1:07:12 – (Both juries)
Sandra Sharp – 2:16:41 – (Both juries)
Charlene Elmore – 3:30:07 – (Lyle’s jury)

VIDEO 41
Pamela LiCausi – 6:30 – (OPJ)
Pamela LiCausi – 37:22 – (Both juries)
Emanuel Zlotolow – 48:42 – (Both juries)
Virginia Lord – 1:51:56 – (Both juries)
Terry Baralt – 1:55:20 – (Both juries)
Terry Baralt – 3:30:45 – (OPJ)

VIDEO 42
Terry Baralt – 26:06 – (Both juries)
Peter Cano – 1:42:19 – (Both juries)
Janet Stoltzfus – 2:11:38 – (Erik’s jury)
Barbara Zussman – 2:49:16 – (Erik’s jury)
Casey Whalen – 3:11:29 – (Erik’s jury)
Casey Whalen – 4:07:14 – (OPJ)

VIDEO 43
Casey Whalen – 13:57 – (Erik’s jury)
Kathleen Bulow-Cohen – 1:29:48 – (Erik’s jury)

VIDEO 44
Leslie Elmore – 25:18 – (Erik’s jury)
Barbara Howarth – 39:45 – (Erik’s jury)
Norman Puls – 1:31:04 – (Erik’s jury)

VIDEO 45
Skip Lowe – 32:44 – (Both juries)
Catharina Whalen – 51:17 – (Erik’s jury)
Douglas Doss – 1:20:25 – (Erik’s jury)

VIDEO 46
No witnesses

VIDEO 47
Mary Theresa Dominguez – 6:04 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 48
Lyle Menendez – 0:00 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 49
Lyle Menendez – 0:00 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 50
Lyle Menendez – 0:00 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 51
Lyle Menendez – 0:00 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 52
Lyle Menendez – 3:38 – (Both juries)
Lyle Menendez – 31:38 – (Lyle’s jury)
Lyle Menendez – 1:00:32 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 53
Lyle Menendez – 2:45 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 54
Lyle Menendez – 1:05:11 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 55
Lyle Menendez – 0:00 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 55
Lyle Menendez – 0:00 – (Both juries)
Lyle Menendez – 51:10 – (Lyle’s jury)

VIDEO 57
No witnesses

VIDEO 58
Leslie Zoeller – 0:00 – (Both juries)
Erik Menendez – 15:55 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 59
Erik Menendez – 0:00 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 60
Erik Menendez – 0:00 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 61
Erik Menendez – 0:00 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 62
Erik Menendez – 0:00 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 63
Erik Menendez – 0:00 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 64
Erik Menendez – 3:37 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 65
Erik Menendez – 0:00 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 66
No witnesses

VIDEO 67
Erik Menendez – 0:00 – (Both juries)
Erik Menendez – 1:56:57 – (Erik’s jury)

VIDEO 68
Donovan Goodreau – 12:29 – (Both juries)
Traci Baker – 58:43 – (Both juries)
Marta Cano – 1:34:16 – (Both juries)
Armando Lopez – 2:04:55 – (Both juries)
Andy Cano – 2:16:24 – (Erik’s jury)
David Mraovitch – 3:13:59 – (Erik’s jury)

VIDEO 69
Ann Tyler – 0:00 – (Erik’s jury)

VIDEO 70
Ann Tyler – 13:50 – (OPJ)
Ann Tyler – 1:06:00 – (Erik’s jury)

VIDEO 71
Ann Tyler – 0:00 – (Erik’s jury)

VIDEO 72
Ann Burgess – 0:00 – (Both juries)
Ann Burgess – 1:06:23 – (OPJ)
Ann Burgess – 1:35:39 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 73
Ann Burgess – 0:00 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 74
Ann Burgess – 0:00 – (Erik’s jury)
Ann Burgess – 2:52:38 – (OPJ)

VIDEO 75
John Conte – 0:00 – (OPJ)

VIDEO 76
Ann Burgess – 26:30 – (OPJ)
Ann Burgess – 28:51 – (Erik’s jury)

VIDEO 77
Stuart Hart – 0:00 – (Lyle’s jury)

VIDEO 78
John Conte – 0:00 – (Lyle’s jury)
John Conte – 42:04 – (OPJ)
John Conte – 1:55:36 (Lyle’s jury)

VIDEO 79
No witnesses

VIDEO 80
John Conte – 0:00 – (Lyle’s jury)

VIDEO 81
Joan Vander Molen – 0:00 – (Both juries)
Patricia Andersen – 35:31 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 82
Carlos Baralt – 19:04 – (Both juries)
Carlos Baralt – 1:19:20 – (OPJ)
Carlos Baralt – 1:24:35 – (Both juries)
Carlos Baralt – 2:37:28 – (Lyle’s jury)

VIDEO 83
Kerry English – 0:00 – (Both juries)
Jon Nickel – 57:05 – (Both juries)
Edward Fenno – 1:06:33 – (Both juries)
Edward Fenno – 2:37:20 – (Erik’s jury)

VIDEO 84
Edwin Cox – 0:00 – (Both juries)
Roger Smith – 42:27 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 85
Leslie Zoeller – 33:49 – (Both juries)
Leslie Zoeller – 1:08:23 – (Erik’s jury)

VIDEO 86
No witnesses

VIDEO 87
No witnesses

VIDEO 88
John Conte – 30:33 – (Lyle’s jury)

VIDEO 89
Judalon Smyth – 0:00 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 90
Warden Emory – 8:30 – (Both juries)
Judalon Smyth – 44:12 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 91
Judalon Smyth – 39:54 – (Erik’s jury)
Judalon Smyth – 42:50 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 92
No witnesses

VIDEO 93
Ann Burgess – 0:00 – (Both juries)
Ann Burgess – 1:26:00 – (Lyle’s jury)
Ann Burgess – 1:41:07 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 94
Ann Burgess – 0:00 – (Both juries)
Ann Burgess – 2:17:03 – (Erik’s jury)

VIDEO 95
Cynthia Erdelyi – 0:00 – (Both juries)
BOTH DEFENSES REST – 49:32

REBUTTAL PHASE

VIDEO 96
Andrew Valentine – 8:58 – (Erik’s jury)
Carol Black – 1:06:24 – (Erik’s jury)
Antoinette Loden – 1:18:07 – (Erik’s jury)
Grant Walker – 2:05:34 – (Both juries)
Leon Bartek – 3:39:14 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 97
No witnesses

VIDEO 98
Flor De Maria Suria – 0:00 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 99
Jamie Pisarcik – 0:00 – (Both juries)
Jamie Pisarcik – 9:45 – (Lyle’s jury)
Jamie Pisarcik – 26:00 – (Both juries)
Jamie Pisarcik – 2:50:07 – (Lyle’s jury)

VIDEO 100
Brian Andersen – 40:55 – (OPJ)
Brian Andersen – 1:03:00 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 101
Pat Heffernan – 49:16 – (Erik’s jury)

VIDEO 102
Brian Andersen – 25:25 – (Lyle’s jury)
Marlene Eisenberg – 37:12 – (Lyle’s jury)

VIDEO 103
Brian Andersen – 0:00 – (Both juries)
Karen Farrell – 1:34:11 – (Both juries)
Marlene Eisenberg – 2:08:44 – (Both juries)
Marlene Eisenberg – 2:53:13 – (Erik’s jury)
Leslie Zoeller – 2:55:08 – (Both juries)

VIDEO 104
Guy DeLisio – 3:07 – (Erik’s jury)

VIDEO 105
William Vicary – 0:00 – (Erik’s jury)

VIDEO 106
Leslie Zoeller – 16:00 – (Both juries)
Ann Ingraham – 22:36 – (Both juries)
Virginia Valdry – 25:50 – (Both juries)
Mark Slotkin – 30:37 – (Both juries)
Mark Heffernan – 1:25:57 – (Both juries)
William Genego – 1:55:00 – (Lyle’s jury)
Timothy Custer – 2:43:27 – (Lyle’s jury)
Les Peckins – 2:47:37 – (Both juries)
Cynthia Erdelyi – 3:08:35 – (Both juries)
Leslie Zoeller – 3:42:54 – (Both juries)
Leslie Zoeller – 3:59:34 – (Lyle’s jury)
Leslie Zoeller – 4:10:07 – (Erik’s jury)
Cynthia Erdelyi – 4:18:45 – (Erik’s jury)

END OF TESTIMONY